Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Ethnographic Description

The purpose of this ethnographic description will be to explore the differences in teaching styles that are promoted in the Western world (i.e. Europe and the U.S.) and West Africa (i.e. Mali). The event that I will be referring to throughout this description will be the one of the African dance classes held during the Rhythm of Change Festival (February 21-23). The dance class, instructed by Solo Sana, relied primarily on the swift nature of West African dancing, which kept all the students on their toes. Interestingly enough, the class flowed exceptionally well despite its lack of a clear distinction between the instructor and the students attending. Nowhere could one observe the hierarchical teaching paradigms that are a hallmark of western education. Instead, what one could observe was a great sense of community. Both the instructor and the students were interacting in such a fundamental way that there was no need to divide up the stage nor was there a need to explain steps more than once. Furthermore, none of the colorful language that distinguishes western dance forms (e.g. relevés, plié, etc.) was implemented at all. What we had instead was the showcasing of methods by the instructor without a word – everything was explained through examples and examples alone. The students, for the most part Brown University students, were indeed challenged by the foreign teaching style that Solo Sana implemented while a portion of the class (which I can only presume to be veterans to the dance style as a whole) were quick to understand the instructor’s steps without hesitation. At the same time, the population present was also composed of university professors and visiting artists which provided the class with an interesting mixture of performers on the stage.
In terms of musicians present, there was a small ensemble of drummers playing the dunduns and djembes of all shapes and sizes. The importance of music in West African dance styles cannot be overstated. The polyrhythmic nature of the music makes it quintessential to the development of the dance style. In fact, there are no barriers between the dancers and the musicians, which is an interesting take on the relationship between what we would call an audience and the performers. The musicians will establish a bass rhythm so that dancing can take place while the djembe drummers will, in a way, establish the nature of the movement explored by means of the dancer’s upper body. The great thing about the presence of live music is that, throughout the class, there is an immense amount of opportunities for the dancers to interact with the drummers present, which then grants the dance style a certain dynamicity that is not observed in other genres entirely.

Overall, I found Solo Sana’s take on teaching to be an interesting take on dancing as both a practice and a social convention. While we might be used to categorically segregating the dance floor into different sectors and further hierarchizing the class by establishing the presence of an instructor and a class, there are still novel ways in which the same material can be explored in, perhaps, more organic ways. I further have to praise the great interactions that can take place with both other dancers and the musicians throughout the span of just one dance alone which I believe should be championed in more dance styles.